Make your voice (and face) sound and look more alive – easy practice drill

If you feel awkward staring into a camera lens, you are fighting your own biology. Your nervous system interprets the unblinking stare of a lens as a threat or rejection, even if your brain doesn’t. This can lead to many things, including causing your facial muscles to go flat and turn into what actors might call “Dead Eyes.”

In this episode, we use Dr. Stephen Porges’ Polyvagal Theory and the Still Face Experiment to explain why your face goes numb when you hit record, and you’ll learn how to override it using a specific acting drill.

Key Takeaways:

  1. The Anatomy of “Dead Eyes”: Why your Social Engagement System shuts down when looking at a lens.
  2. Why the camera lens triggers a subconscious threat response.
  3. Stanislavski’s Circles: How to use the “Medium Circle” to trick your brain into feeling safe.
  4. The Drill: My “Talk to the Face” drill to warm up your on-camera presence.

Resources

Join the Lab & Get the Newsletter: https://stereoforest.com

Polyvagal Theory (Dr. Stephen Porges): https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12302812

Stanislavski Circles of Attention: https://www.theatreworkout.com/post/stanislavski-3-circles-of-attention

The Still Face Experiment (Dr. Ed Tronick): https://www.gottman.com/blog/research-still-face-experiment

Why Still Face was game changer – https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/tech-support/202307/why-the-still-face-experiment-was-a-game-changer

Still Face Experiment and connection – https://psychhelp.com.au/what-does-the-still-face-experiment-teach-us-about-connection/

Eyes as a Threat: https://psychcentral.com/health/identifying-psychopathic-stare#what-is-it

Research on Eye Contact with the Camera: https://jov.arvojournals.org/article.aspx?articleid=2810811

“Dead Eyes” Podcast by Connor Ratliff: https://headgum.com/dead-eyes

Chapters

00:00 The Disconnect: Why You Feel Awkward Recording

01:25 Welcome to the Podcast Performance Lab

01:47 Polyvagal Theory: The Social Engagement System

03:25 The “Still Face” Experiment Explained

05:35 Biology: Why the Lens Looks Like a Predator

06:33 Acting Theory: Stanislavski’s Circles of Attention

08:41 The Personalization Technique: Speaking to One Person

11:22 Drill: “Talk to the Face” (Using a Photo)

14:36 Advanced Drill: Visualization & Scanning

18:22 Recommendation: The “Dead Eyes” Podcast

==========================

About and Support

==========================

Written, edited, and hosted by Jen deHaan.

Find this show on YouTube at https://youtube.com/@jdehaan

Website at https://stereoforest.com/lab

Get StereoForest’s newsletter for podcasting resources at https://stereoforest.com/newsletter

Produced by StereoForest https://stereoforest.com

Contact Jen at https://jendehaan.com

==========================

Support

Your support will help this show continue. Funds will go towards hosting and music licensing for this show and others on StereoForest. This show is produced by an independent HUMAN artist directly affected by the state of the industry. StereoForest does not have any funding or additional support.

Support the Show

  1. Like this episode or show and want more? Support us with a one-time tip: https://StereoForest.com/tips
  2. We love our podcast host Capitvate.fm! Contact to ask me anything, anytime. You can support the shows by signing up with Captivate here: https://www.captivate.fm/signup?ref=yzjiytz
  3. We have our newsletters on Kit.com. We also have our tip form with them, and sell products on their platform. Easy, and they don't take a cut! Check Kit out and support the show using this: https://partners.kit.com/ijdkivtf8ndd
  4. Transcriptions by MacWhisper. I use and love the Pro version (subscription free!) - you can get it too using this link: https://gumroad.com/a/20303251/ivpqk
  5. Schedule posts? We use Metricool (reasonable for multiple accounts/brands/shows). Support us using our link: https://f.mtr.cool/VZBOZR
  6. Support the show and get creative templates and assets: https://share.uppbeat.io/p4od8inwhc2j


==========================

About Jen

Host: Jen deHaan is the founder of StereoForest. With a background of over 20 years in tech, education, & instructional design and 10 years in improv and performance, Jen brings systems and scientific approach to media production.

Jen's website: https://jendehaan.com

This podcast is a StereoForest production. Made and produced in British Columbia, Canada.

Transcript

WEBVTT

::

so there you are creating a video and you know that potentially thousands of people

::

could be watching that video one day but you're sitting alone in your office

::

looking at a wall or something and you're sitting there talking to an inanimate object

::

this is the same if you're recording into a microphone too it's inanimate it's just sitting

::

there and this creates a disconnect in your brain and that disconnect can create anxiety and that

::

anxiety can affect the most expressive parts of your face or your voice or both and that can result

::

in what actors call dead eyes. So if you're feeling awkward when you're staring into that lens,

::

you're actually correct to feel that way because you're talking to something that can't respond.

::

So in this episode, we're going to do a drill to help you override that internal thing that's going

::

on for you. And this is so you can look and you can feel more like yourself when you're making

::

your audio or video content. Welcome to the Podcast Performance Lab. I'm your host,

::

Janda Hahn, and in this show, we take the most effective tools from unscripted improvised

::

performance and behavioral psychology and apply those things directly to your video and audio

::

content. So let's get into the science of why things like dead eyes even happen in the first

::

place, and it has to do with your nervous system. We need to start with the anatomy, but I'll keep

::

it pretty quick here. So the polyvagal theory was developed by Dr. Stephen Porges, and that theory

::

explains how we connect with other human beings, and it has to do with that nervous system. And part

::

of this is that we have a social engagement system, as it's called, and this social engagement system

::

turns on when we connect actively with other human beings. Like when we see a person, we send

::

these signals back and forth of what's happening right now. And engaging that social engagement

::

system happens when we feel safe with that other person. And this also affects our physiology while

::

it's happening because we give these signals to the other person using our eyes and our voice.

::

Like our voices, they become more melodic. Our eyes, they have the muscle systems around the

::

edges of them engaged. They sort of crinkle when we smile and that's how we communicate

::

with other people and that's how it affects our feelings. So now think about your camera,

::

for example, it doesn't do any of these things, but you're still trying to engage with it. You're

::

looking at it. You're staring at it. It gives you nothing back. That can be really difficult

::

when we're recording our content. There's a famous experiment called the still face experiment,

::

and it was done by a Dr. Ed Tronick. And in this study, a parent plays with their baby and everything

::

is going great. Then the parent actually stops moving their face and just stares blankly at their

::

baby. And the baby tries naturally to get a reaction, but then that baby gets frustrated,

::

it disengages, and it gets upset. So this is a study where they discovered this still face thing,

::

And it can sort of happen to you too when you're recording.

::

Like, not long into recording a solo episode

::

where you're just trying to engage with that camera lens or microphone,

::

you're pouring all of your energy into that piece of hardware.

::

But the hardware is inanimate, obviously,

::

and it gives you absolutely nothing back.

::

And your nervous system will actually interpret that feeling,

::

that happening as some kind of rejection and then it reacts to that so your body switches gears and

::

it moves out of that really safe social engagement mode that's the one from the study where you feel

::

really safe with the other person where they're giving you these signals back and you're giving

::

them that this back and forth where everybody's saying hey we're all on the same page it moves

::

out of that into sort of a defensive kind of mode. And this switch happening is really expensive to

::

your metabolic system. You're trying to force a smile or force showing emotions or force showing

::

that engagement that you're not actually feeling. It's not actually happening. So that's where the

::

dissonance in your mind happens. Like your mouth is smiling, but your eyes are dead. And those dead

::

eyes just don't match the smile that you're throwing out there. Your eyes are flat because

::

the muscles around them aren't engaged. And to make matters worse, the lens kind of looks like a

::

threat, scientifically speaking at least, because predators in the animal kingdom in general, they

::

stare at their prey or whatever they're setting their sights on with this large fixed unblinked

::

unblinking dilated pupil, which is kind of like a camera lens in appearance. So even though it's

::

just a scientific thing, subconsciously you could be reacting a little bit to that as well. So I'll

::

put all the links to all of the science here from the polyvagal theory right through to the unblinking

::

eye thing in the description. Now that we know the biology involved in all of this, we need a way to

::

deal with it when we're actually making our audio and video content. And one way to do this

::

is changing how we perceive the camera itself. And the first part of this is acting theory.

::

And then I'm going to give you a drill that borrows from improv. So Stanislavski, who's best known for

::

method acting, had this concept that can be pretty useful in this context. And it's called the

::

circles of attention. Now imagine three circles, a small one, a medium one, and a large one.

::

And the small circle is just you alone. So you're focusing in on yourself, like you're wondering,

::

how do I look? Is my hair okay? How do I sound? All those sort of things.

::

The medium-sized circle is just you and one other person. And this is where the connection really

::

happens. And now the large circle is the whole room. It's the whole audience, really, or the

::

millions of people watching your video, potentially. So the dead eyes, they happen in acting when

::

you're thinking about that large circle, the one with millions of video watchers, because

::

that audience is invisible. Even if you're on a stage, those bright lights effectively do the

::

same thing because you can't really see the audience too well but you still like even without

::

seeing them and all of these cases you feel the weight of all of those eyeballs all of those

::

potential viewers who are judging you and that puts a ton of pressure on your nervous system

::

you can also get stuck in that small circle that's one with just you in it because you can get really

::

self-conscious about like talking at a wall, for example, like what I'm doing right now with the

::

microphone. And even if you're just alone talking at that wall, you start monitoring your own speech,

::

even though you're the only one there to hear it. So the fix for this is to just stay in that

::

medium-sized circle, the one with you and one other person, because this way you can sort of

::

trick your brain into believing that the lens is actually another person that you're talking to,

::

right? So in improv and acting, we use a technique called personalization. And that means like that

::

we're not talking to an audience, a whole group of people like we're doing in a show or in a podcast.

::

you're not talking to listeners the whole demographic you're talking to one person

::

the individual the one listener you and that's because we can only really talk to a person and

::

worry about what that one person thinks now actors and other professionals who speak to the lens like

::

news broadcasters really noteworthy ones you've heard of they'll use a technique where they're

::

Imagining a person that they're talking to specifically, like they'll take somebody that they really like in their life, like a partner or a really close friend, and they'll imagine that they're delivering their entire newscast or their monologue or whatever it is to that specific person.

::

And that's what adds the connection, that feeling, because if you're talking to a whole group, that becomes really performative.

::

Like when I was a dance fitness instructor, I taught a group of around 20 people or so at the same time.

::

And when I was up on stage, most of the time I delivered all of my teaching to all of them.

::

It was very performative. It was very big.

::

It wasn't very personal, except when I did do personal stuff within, but most of the class was very performative in nature.

::

But when I'm doing a podcast, I imagine that I'm talking to you, one person on the other side of the lens or the other side of the microphone.

::

And that's a very different feeling for me and hopefully for you, the listener.

::

And when I deliver these, I'm always thinking about what you, the individual, thinks.

::

You, the listener, who I'm delivering these things to.

::

And that's when we get more of that social engagement, that theory, that system back.

::

And it will change our voices.

::

It will change what our faces look like.

::

So here's that drill to make this happen for you, if it's an issue.

::

So just a quick note, if you want these tips and the drills that I do in these podcast episodes as written text-based instructions,

::

you can always subscribe to my newsletter at StereoForest.com to get them delivered to you in that format.

::

So this is the drill I call talk to the face, very literal,

::

and it kind of creates an external safety cue for your brain to use while you record.

::

The first step is to pick someone you actually like or love,

::

somebody that you really trust and someone who makes you smile and feel good and feel safe

::

because that's where we're getting those right emotions from.

::

So you're probably not picking someone from your professional life for this one.

::

And the next step is to print out a photo of that person

::

or pull it up on your phone and put it directly next to your hardware.

::

And you could do this using something like a phone holder,

::

some kind of stand if you're using your phone.

::

Just don't cover the lens with whatever is holding this photo.

::

put it right next to the lens or the microphone.

::

Now, research shows that looking two to five degrees below the lens,

::

below the center of the lens,

::

looks like the eye is actually making direct eye contact with the viewer.

::

So if you're making like a video podcast, that will be relevant to you.

::

Because you do want to make it look like you're making eye contact

::

with the person listening to you.

::

So having that photo right next to the lens, even for videos that you're actually going to put online, can work.

::

And I'll also link the study with that information about the degrees and the eye contact and the lens in the show notes.

::

So now for the next step is to just start recording and ignore that lens.

::

Just look right at the photo.

::

Speak your video's intro to that person in the photo directly and practice directly doing that, literally, by using their name.

::

So I might go something like, hey, Carissa, I've been waiting to tell you about the fact it actually snowed on Christmas Eve.

::

And my new husky mix absolutely loved it.

::

I've never taken her out in the snow before.

::

Anyways, that's just an example.

::

And you can cut out the part with their name or you can just keep this particular step for practice only.

::

And then compare your output and notice what changes in your content.

::

Like you might notice your voice changes, your pitch might drop when you're talking to this person instead of talking directly to your hardware.

::

Or notice any visual changes.

::

If you're taking video, like pay attention to your face and how your face might change

::

or your body language overall, how you hold yourself on the chair.

::

It might change.

::

So you're probably overall notice yourself getting a little bit less performy or a little

::

bit less stiff.

::

Now, it's not going to look like you're delivering something to a large audience, and that's good.

::

You're just kind of talking to that person that you know, that person in the photo.

::

Once you've done this a few times, you can then remove the training wheels, as it were.

::

The advanced version, the pro version of this is to just remove that photo and stare at that lens or just a few degrees below it.

::

And you're going to use your visual imagination at this step.

::

So this is an acting technique where you're endowing an object with human qualities.

::

You're visualizing your friend's face, where the lens is, and you're just kind of projecting

::

that mental image onto the lens.

::

And you want to try to actively look at them like you would naturally in person if you're

::

doing video.

::

And on this note, humans have a huge range from not being able to visually imagine things

::

to being able to really hyper visualize things in their mind.

::

And most people are somewhere in between those two things.

::

So that's probably statistically you.

::

But if you can't visualize at all,

::

which is like up to 3% of the population,

::

you can keep a photo there

::

until you're comfortable to remove it

::

or you don't have to remove it either.

::

You can always have it there.

::

It does work.

::

So an important thing here

::

is that you don't want to like passively stare at the lens or your visualization on top of the lens

::

if you're at that point. Think of it this way. It's like if you're thinking about your notes or

::

your script, you're really in your head. And when people are really in their head, their eyes sort

::

of just fixate on the person that they're talking to in this sort of passive way because they're in

::

their head. They're thinking about what do I need to say, right? It's kind of this distraction when

::

you're trying to remember a line or you get this glazed overlook like I'm not quite there. Like if

::

you, for example, notice somebody who's not really listening to you when they're talking, it's kind of

::

like that look as well. So instead you want to scan the person that you're envisioning, like you're

::

scanning for their reaction to what you're saying and that can kind of give you that body language

::

or the signals in your face that you're really engaged.

::

You're really paying attention to their reactions.

::

And those micro movements in your eyes,

::

they make you look more alive and more engaged

::

and they remove the dead eyes look.

::

So now a couple more things about those dead eyes.

::

So make sure that you remember to blink if you're making a video

::

because if we stare, we sort of change how we naturally blink.

::

So we want to make sure we aren't reducing our blink rate too much, and we want to keep that part natural.

::

And also your lighting.

::

If you're making videos, make sure that people can even see your eyes in the first place.

::

Dead eyes is biology, really.

::

It's human nature.

::

And if this happens in your videos or it happens in your voice, if you're making audio content,

::

you'll pick up that something is slightly off when you listen to it.

::

Your listeners will be as well.

::

And it will make your content a little bit harder to connect with.

::

There's going to be that disconnect there because you aren't your natural self.

::

So you can use these tools from acting and from improv to help you out to come across more natural when you're talking to the camera or into the microphone because you'll feel more natural doing so.

::

if you can imagine visualizing a person that you know that you're just talking to that person

::

get that picture next to the camera to help you out give it a few tries and see what happens

::

see what the difference is and see if that will work for your next episodes and if you're still

::

here i just want to mention before i go the great podcast series that's actually called dead eyes

::

It's by a really well-known improviser and actor called Connor Ratliff.

::

And it's about his experience of being told that he has dead eyes.

::

And then everything that went from there.

::

It's a really great series.

::

It's a lot about how we deal as humans with things like rejection.

::

So there's a lot of learning to be had in that series.

::

It's also just a great story.

::

Really great guests as well.

::

So I recommend that one.

::

And that's all I have for this episode.

::

Bye for now.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *